What is the Difference Between Good Debt and Bad Debt?
For most Americans, the simple truth is that carrying debt is just a part of life. Let’s make things a little clearer by first examining the percentage of Americans within various demographics who have never been in debt. For baby boomers, that percentage is 5.1%. For Generation Xers, the percentage is a little higher, at 8.2%, and for millennial’s that percentage is 11%.
These alarmingly low percentages speak to the overwhelming majority of Americans within those demographics who currently are in debt – and those percentages are staggeringly high – all hovering near 80%. (Baby boomers: 80.9%; Generation Xers: 79.9%; and millennial’s: 81.5%.) On its face, debt is simply borrowing money for the present, at the expense of the future.
Debt certainly has a negative connotation for many, and the above statistics speak to a situation that requires further exploration and invites many questions. Why are so many Americans taking on debt? Is all debt “bad?” Is some debt “good?” Are there, in fact, differences between good and bad debt? Let’s take a closer look.
As a general rule, if a type of debt can help you enhance your earnings potential or net worth, then it can be considered “good” debt. For example, good debt can take the form of student loans (though this has become a subject of recent debate), home mortgages, home equity loans, debt consolidation loans and small business loans.
Borrowing for educational needs is still considered a form of good debt because a college or technical degree generally leads to a greater ease of employment and higher earnings potential. The return on investment over the course of a career makes it easier to pay back student loans, particularly with a degree in the STEM (science, technology, engineering and mathematics) fields.
Mortgages and Other Real Estate Loans
A residential home mortgage is considered a form of good debt because of the straightforward strategy of buying a home and living in it for many years before selling it at a profit. Prior to the bursting of the real estate bubble burst in 2007, median housing prices in the U.S. showed an annual increase of 6.4% from 1968 to 2004.
Following a multi-year period of decline and stagnation, since 2012, U.S. median home prices have been increasing at a similar rate, making home mortgages a form of good debt once again. Meantime, renting out a residential property backed by a mortgage can also generate income, while debt taken out for commercial real estate investments can generate cash flow and capital gains as well.
Finally, low-interest rate home equity loans or lines of credit at reasonably low interest rates can be utilized as a form of debt consolidation to pay off higher interest-rate credit card debt.
Small Business Loans and Debt Consolidation Loans
Small business loans that foster entrepreneurial endeavors are considered a form of good debt in that they can lead to the freedom of not requiring an employer to supply a job and steady paycheck. With a small business loan, the right combination of ambition, brains, hard work and luck can lead to exceptional wealth creation and freedom.
Meantime, debt consolidation loans can be a form of good debt that results in interest expense savings for an individual carrying multiple forms of unsecured high-interest rate debt.
A debt consolidation loan that is issued at a lower overall blended interest rate not only results in considerable interest expense savings over the long-term, but also streamlines the debt repayment process by replacing multiple creditors and monthly payments with one single creditor and payment each month.
The potential drawback, however, is that an irresponsible debtor may simply spend the interest expense savings that result from a debt consolidation loan.
Bad debt can be characterized as debt that cannot lead to an increase in earnings potential or net worth, as well as any debt taken for the purchase of depreciating assets.
The general rule is that if an item can’t appreciate in value, its purchase should not be funded by debt. At the top of that list resides borrowing for the purchase of a new car. Auto loans are a form of bad debt because the value of a new car immediately depreciates as soon as it is driven off of the lot and becomes a “used” car.
Examples of other expensive, quickly depreciating assets include high-end luxury label clothing and large flat-screen televisions. None of these items should ever be paid for by debt. If you don’t have the cash sitting in the bank to buy these items, consider making adjustments. Buying a good quality, pre-owned vehicle in cash is never a bad idea, for example.
Good thrift stores that offer name-brand label clothing for a relative pittance are a viable alternative, as are apps such as OfferUp and Poshmark.
Credit Card Debt
Credit card debt is perhaps the worst form of debt of all, as the high interest rates often associated with credit cards can result in a protracted period of repayment during which interest expense accumulates.
Almost all purchases funded by credit card debt involve consumables that will never appreciate in value, and with few exceptions – such as for the purchase of an online business creation course or similar vocational training – will not lead to an increase in earnings potential.
This is not to say that credit cards are entirely “bad” – when used responsibly they are a highly useful tool for building a credit score and can be a useful budgeting tool. It’s when they are used improperly to fund a lifestyle beyond one’s means that credit cards quickly become a form of bad debt.
Dealing with high interest auto loan debt was difficult for me and my wife
Dealing with high interest auto loan debt was difficult for me and my wife. We thought we got a good deal, but it actually was a horrible loan. So, we reached out to United Settlement, and they got to work...
No one really wants to go bankrupt, and neither did my family
No one really wants to go bankrupt, and neither did my family. But fortunately, we did not have to go that route. It was our last resort, but United Settlement helped us figure out a way around bankruptcy...
I had been through about 5 different credit counseling agencies before I found United Settlement
I had been through about 5 different credit counseling agencies before I found United Settlement. I had read through their reviews and made the decision to move forward with them. I also was so impressed...
As a business facing some unwanted financial difficulties
As a business facing some unwanted financial difficulties, we were at a loss for what to do next when our debt started to soar. We took a closer look at our financial situation by contacting United Settlement....
I had no clue how to create a debt management plan
I had no clue how to create a debt management plan and in fact, I didn't even know what a debt management plan was. Fortunately, I reached out to United Settlement before I had too much debt to tackle....
Being burdened by debt is one of the biggest struggles we faced as a family
Being burdened by debt is one of the biggest struggles we faced as a family. But these people at United Settlement were very helpful in deciphering the different debts we had and then coming up with a debt...
Student loan debt was my worst enemy before I ran into United Settlement
Student loan debt was my worst enemy before I ran into United Settlement. I really thought I would just have terrible credit for the rest of my life because I will never get out from underneath it. It was...
I never thought about settling our credit and auto loan debts
I never thought about settling our credit and auto loan debts. I honestly thought the only way out of our situation was to go bankrupt. But that all changed when we reached out to United Settlement. We...
We were dealing with extremely high-interest rates on debt
We were dealing with extremely high-interest rates on debt. That made it difficult to make improvements in what we owed. We were pretty much devastated. By our debt because we really wanted to buy a house...
Auto loans are my family’s biggest problem
Auto loans are my family’s biggest problem. Sure, having them is a necessary evil in our modern era. We spent years trying to pay our auto loans off. But the problem was, we never could make headway....
Bankruptcy was not an option I wanted to use
Bankruptcy was not an option I really wanted to use. I wanted to find an alternative to this process that would enable me to get rid of my debt for good without having a bad mark on my credit history. That...
United Settlement was there for me when I could not be there for myself
United Settlement was there for me when I could not be there for myself. I was not sure how to move forward when I had a massive amount of debt. I could not figure out how to get out from under the seemingly...
I had no idea that I could reorganize my utility builds or residential leases
I had no idea that I could reorganize my utility builds or residential leases. But United Settlement helped me see that I could. They were very friendly in telling us about what our options were as a family...
Everybody knows how ridiculous student loans are
Everybody knows how ridiculous student loans are, and that was not lost on me when I chose to take out hundreds of thousands in student loan debt. Relieving a measure of pressure for my student loans was...
Restructuring business debt is not an easy thing to do
Restructuring business debt is not an easy thing to do. But United Settlement was great at helping me figure that out. Understanding financial situations and goals was what I really wanted, and they did...
I had no clue that I was paying more than 100% APR on my small business loan
When I reached out to United Settlement, I had no clue that I was paying more than 100% APR on my small business loan. I could not believe it! But I was paying that much which meant I could not ever get...
Handling my business debt was not something I looked forward to
Handling my business debt was not something I looked forward to. But United Settlement was so patient with my questions and helped me figure out how to handle my debt as a small business owner. I qualified...
I didn't even know what type of interest rates there were and how those affected my debt overall
When I contacted United Settlement, I didn't even know what type of interest rates there were and how those affected my debt overall. So, when I went to go buy a new house, I was shocked to find out that...
Debt settlement is what we signed up for when we were interested in using United Settlement
Debt settlement is what we signed up for when we were interested in using United Settlement. We needed a company to negotiate on our behalf to help us reduce the total amount of debt we owed, and we were...
I had no idea that I could lower my credit card interest rates. But when I contacted United Settlement, they explained to me that I could negotiate my interest rates down lower along with my payoff balance....